RESPONDING

RESPONDING

Written or Oral Response to a Discussion or Debate about Art Work

Visual Art Proficiency Based Graduation Requirements

	Exceeds Standard Advanced 4	Meets Standard Proficient 3	Below Standard Emerging 2	Beginning 1
Organization (sets context, makes argument, defends with evidence, conclusion) PBGR-VA, R2	The student… Evaluates process and meaning; thoroughly communicates a personal reaction to a work of art	The student… Analyzes process and meaning; clearly communicates a personal reaction to a work of art	The student… Identifies process and meaning; communicates some personal reaction to a work of art	The student… Identifies minimal process and meaning; communicates little personal reaction to a work of art
Details/ Evidence from Piece PBGR-VA, R1	Evaluates the main subjects’ symbols and ideas in exemplar work	Analyzes the main subjects’ symbols and ideas in exemplar work	Describes the main subjects’ symbols and ideas in exemplar work	Identifies the main subjects’ symbols and ideas in exemplar work
Knowledge of another culture and/or artistic period PBGR-VA, R2	Evaluates artwork from other cultures, periods and local/global symbol systems	Analyzes artwork, and the impact of art, from other cultures, periods and local/global symbol systems	Describes artwork from other cultures, periods and local/global symbol systems	Identifies artwork from other cultures, periods and local/global symbol systems
Connections Between Content/Concepts in other Disciplines PBGR-VA, R3	Synthesizes the content/ concepts learned in the visual arts and in other disciplines	Analyzes the relationship between the content/concepts learned in the visual arts and in other disciplines	Describes some relationship between the content/concepts learned in the visual arts and in other disciplines	Finds little relationship between the content/concepts learned in the visual arts and in other disciplines
Value gained by personal involvement PBGR-VA, R2	Evaluates the personal value gained through involvement in the arts	Analyzes the personal value gained through involvement in the arts	Describes some of the personal value gained through involvement in the arts	Identifies some personal value gained through involvement in the arts

Exceeds Standard

Advanced

Meets Standard

Proficient

Below Standard

Emerging

Beginning

Organization

(sets context, makes argument, defends with evidence, conclusion)

PBGR-VA, R2

The student…

Evaluates process and meaning; thoroughly communicates a personal reaction to a work of art

The student…

Analyzes process and meaning; clearly communicates a personal reaction to a work of art

The student…

Identifies process and meaning; communicates some personal reaction to a work of art

The student…

Identifies minimal process and meaning; communicates little personal reaction to a work of art

Details/

Evidence from Piece

PBGR-VA, R1

Evaluates the main subjects’ symbols and ideas in exemplar work

Analyzes the main subjects’ symbols and ideas in exemplar work

Describes the main subjects’ symbols and ideas in exemplar work

Identifies the main subjects’ symbols and ideas in exemplar work

Knowledge of another culture and/or artistic period

PBGR-VA, R2

Evaluates artwork from other cultures, periods and local/global symbol systems

Analyzes artwork, and the impact of art, from other cultures, periods and local/global symbol systems

Describes artwork from other cultures, periods and local/global symbol systems

Identifies artwork from other cultures, periods and local/global symbol systems

Connections Between Content/Concepts in other Disciplines

PBGR-VA, R3

Synthesizes the content/ concepts learned in the visual arts and in other disciplines

Analyzes the relationship between the content/concepts learned in the visual arts and in other disciplines

Describes some relationship between the content/concepts learned in the visual arts and in other disciplines

Finds little relationship between the content/concepts learned in the visual arts and in other disciplines

Value gained by personal involvement

PBGR-VA, R2

Evaluates the personal value gained through involvement in the arts

Analyzes the personal value gained through involvement in the arts

Describes some of the personal value gained through involvement in the arts

Identifies some personal value gained through involvement in the arts