Category

Exceeds Standard

Meets Standard

Below Standard

Design Ideas

· Demonstrates sophisticated ideas for the design of the service or system, which reflects awareness of similar work done by others and relevant design standards and regulations.

· Demonstrates clear ideas for the design, which reflects awareness of similar work done by others and relevant design standards and regulations.

· Demonstrates limited ideas for the design, which may not reflect awareness of similar work done by others and relevant design standards and regulation.

Choices

· Provides detailed justification of choices made in finalizing the design, for example, functional, aesthetic, social, economic, technology related and environmental considerations.

· Justifies choices made in finalizing the design, for example, functional, aesthetic, social, economic, technology related and/or environmental considerations.

· Lacks justification of choices made in finalizing the design.

Establishing Criteria

· Demonstrates considerable thought in establishing criteria for evaluating the product, service, or system.

· Uses sophisticated conventions to represent the design.

· Demonstrates thought in establishing criteria for evaluating the product, service or system.

· Uses appropriate conventions to represent the design.

· Lacks criteria for evaluation of the product, service or system.

· Lacks appropriate conventions to represent the product, service or system.

Implementation

· Provides a detailed outline of the planning and implementation steps necessary to create the product, service or system.

· Makes creative adjustments as needed to conform with specified standards or regulations regarding quality or safety.

· Provides evidence of good planning and implementing of steps needed to create the product, service, or system.

· Makes adjustments as needed to conform with specified standards or regulations regarding quality or safety.

·Does not provide description of the steps needed to plan and implement the product, service or system.

· Lacks evidence of adjustments needed to conform with specified standards or regulations regarding quality or safety.

Product Evaluation

· Provides sophisticated evaluation of the product, service or system in terms of the criteria established in the design proposal and with reference to information gathered.

· Provides accurate and in-depth comparisons with similar work done by others.

· Provides thoughtful evaluation of the product, service, or system in terms of criteria established in the design proposal and with reference to information gathered.

· Demonstrates relevant comparisons with similar work done by others.

· Exhibits limited evaluation of the product, service or system in terms of the criteria established in the design proposal and with reference to information gathered.

· Does not provide sufficient comparisons with similar work done by others.